GloineFiodh's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Drawing A Flash]

Not good.

This is not good, even for someone who is inexperienced. This could be done in minutes and look better if you put a little thought into it. I just don't see the point in submitting this. Awful graphics and animation, and no plot. Music is ok though. Overall, you need to try harder and learn not to submit every animation you do to newgrounds. Try taking more time and practice drawing, by a wacom pad maybe if your serious about this. Good luck.

[TC Round 3: Wacky Races]

Amazing.

After reading what a reviewer below me said, I realize how underrated you really are. I saw one of your other flash movies on the front page and loved, although I didn't really understand it. Your animation is flawless, and your drawings are awesome. I wouldn't be surprised if I saw something like this on TV. Your characters are so original and full of life you can't help but like them, and by the end of the episode I actually felt upset at what had happened after he displayed such sportsmanship. I really hope more of your work will be noticed and front paged. I know you will be going near the top of my favorite authors and this submission will be favorited as well. Excellent work, keep it up. Good Luck.

[Xionic Madness 1.5]

Impressed.

It was weird to see a lot of the stuff I think of in your flash. Like the chainsaw sword and what not. The first one didn't captivate me as much as this one, but one thing I didn't like what was the animation. The drawings and character design were excellent, but some of the animation wasn't so great, probably because Krinkles mastered it and I'm used to his animation. Still, nice job, captivating story, great ideas and new concepts. Just try to smooth up your animation. Can't wait for Madness 08.

Xionico responds:

thanks :D

[Awesome Center Redux]

Oh boy.

I loved that one and I loved the additions you made. ZOMBIE CANCER! You have great timing and great jokes. The ending still makes me laugh. Just improve some of your animations and I'd say you've got a perfect ten.

[Ghost Out Part 3]

I'm shocked.

It was so good, and I'm surprised this came out! This inspired me to animate. I loved the first 2 and the third is just as good if not better. Your writing, animation and color scheme combined with the cliche dialogue is a surefire win. I hope to see this win some awards and go onto the front page. One complaint is to make it longer! I know that it was already a good length, but at the end, I had felt like not to much happened. Keep them coming please! This was excellent.

RedMongoose responds:

I really would have loved to have made it longer but my computer was starting to slow down horribly just from working on this one. Thanks for the review I'll get started on part 4 right away.

[Rotten Antenna]

Excellent.

It was such a simple concept, but animated so well. I never thought I'd be so entertained by something so vague and story less, (at least it was to me, I couldn't find any meaning) but I truly was completely captivated. As a reviewer below said, this was very inspiring and excellently animated. I loved the shadow and lightning effects, and the drastic camera changes of that long shot to the ultra close up of the mans face. I found the slightly choppy frame by frame a good contrast since most of the other animation was tweens and perfectly smooth. Overall, I really loved it and will now be looking at future and past works. Wonderful job.

[Gun Vs Chainsaw]

What are you 9 years old?

I got a kick out of that one. Anyways, great animation. It got better and better as it progressed. By the end I found myself really enjoying myself with all the action going on.

[Purgatory Pizza Teaser]

Very funny

I thought it was very funny, but the drawings were'nt great. I loved it and really look forward to seeing this series. Good job overall.

[MK vs DC short]

I wanted a little more

I would of liked to see more action maybe. The sprite animation was ok, and it was kind of funny I guess, but a little fighting would have been good in there, or less on that whole laughing scene. Overall, not bad.

[Bioshock Silent Movie]

Not bad at all

It isn't great, but it isn't bad. I love Bioshock, so I would of liked to see more Bioshock related humor regarding story maybe. But I did enjoy the little things in the backgrounds, don't trust Irish rogues and what not. Animation was bad. I think if your drawings had been better, that would have raised the score a lot. And it really wasn't that funny. I mean, I like the idea and all, but the humor wasn't great. I think you relied on one joke to much with the plasmids. It was very good for a first short and I'd like to see more of these silent movie shorts.
Good luck